Auction house Yes/No?

Auction house ruined diablo 3 it is a fact.

BUT!!!!!!!!! The only thing worst than an auction house system that diablo 3 had is...... having no system at all.

Anything > diablo's auction house > path of exiles nothing.

It is the reason I stopped playing hardcore for months. Then new leagues are announced while I have not did maps or anything in forever so I start playing again only to realize after about a week the reason I originally stopped.

Add a map where people can set up stalls to sell stuff like some games have or something..... anything would be better than nothing......

"

Aegon wrote:

I think aRPGs suffer if the pool of items is contributed to by everyone and indexed with the efficiency of an auction house... People realize that they are just one out of many many thousands and that their chance of actually finding a worthwhile item is relative to that ratio.

Since most people play aRPGs for the looting aspect (assumption) this kinda sucks the fun out of it.

I agree but what sucks the fun even more is actually finding relatively decent stuff but not ever being able to get rid of it.

"

BurnYugo wrote:

Of course we need that auction house.....
I get bored of spending more time, trying to sell items instead of playing...

That game is dying cause of the absence of a trading system, because the forum one is nothing, for me.

Give us an auction house and let us play more instead of sitting in town trying to sell!

exactly.. having to spam chat all day to buy items because only 5% of players at most even post items on forum to sell is extremely boring.

No to AH

Yes to Trading Post where item's can be listed and displayed (and searched for like the Diablo 3 AH, just no bidding or anything).

Auction house its a must have - but need a strong firewall and staff to support this.
I played "aika on-line" for few year and have a excellent auction house whit direct mail.
But just one lame player "destroy" all economy game with hack and put several "cash" items to sell day and night .. (case brazil).
... but trade items whit auction house its A LOT better.

Say no to simple trade channel, sounds "romantic" and retrograde.

ps: poor english ... ^^.

YES , cause i just hate lowballer !

"

cypherrage wrote:

No to AH

Yes to Trading Post where item's can be listed and displayed.

"

cypherrage wrote:

No to AH

Yes to Trading Post where item's can be listed and displayed (and searched for like the Diablo 3 AH, just no bidding or anything).

+1 to this.

Basically a better and properly indexed version of the trading forum. Trading can still require one to one interaction between players, there just needs to be a better way to find those players to trade with.

Isnt the trading index already achieved with poe.xyz.is?
I think this a absolutely great tool which still allows a lot of personal trading/bartering while being able to search for the exact items you want.

"

cypherrage wrote:

No to AH

Yes to Trading Post where item's can be listed and displayed (and searched for like the Diablo 3 AH, just no bidding or anything).

Yes to this!

"

BurnYugo wrote:

Of course we need that auction house.....
I get bored of spending more time, trying to sell items instead of playing...

That game is dying cause of the absence of a trading system, because the forum one is nothing, for me.

Give us an auction house and let us play more instead of sitting in town trying to sell!

An auction house will result in spending more time trading than now for a lot of people simply because it is more efficient to flip instead of actually playing the game.

No to auction house. I don't have any problems with the way tarding is right now.

"

Kiluvaras wrote:

I can't understand why you fools who came to play this from D3 and actually trying to make this game similar to D3.

This reminds me of real life immigration. Come from a worse country, expecting a better life to another country and try to make it as similar to the one you left as possible and as hard as you can. Never will I understand why...

e: no, AH would hurt the game and economy.