Legal Vs. Ethical in HC

[Removed by Support]

I've never understood players like this in video games. These are video games, not real life moral high grounds.

If you aren't smart enough to write a 10 line AHK macro to hit escape and click somewhere on the screen, then that's your own fault. If you're too lazy, also your own fault.

Just because you decide that it is wrong, doesn't make it wrong. Macros have been used in all online computer games since the dawn of online games.

Explain to me how multi-boxing and running a culler to farm Dominus is "unethical". Explain that to me.

A. It's a video game. How do ethics apply?
B. It isn't against TOS to run multiple instances of the client, so how is it cheating?
C. How does someone else's wealth in the game affect YOUR fun of the game?

This stupid thread reminds me so much of the "self-found" argument. If you want to play self-found, great. But don't go and make threads bitching about how you can't make any currency or you can't find the items you want. If you want to play the game without using the map, go for it. But don't bitch about not being able to figure out where you are going. If you are going to play the game without using hotkeys (which it sounds like you do since you refer to clicking everything), don't bitch about not being able to hit your pots and abilities fast enough.

My point is, how other people play the game doesn't affect YOUR fun and YOUR style of playing the game. Play the game however the hell you want. But don't come here and claim some imaginary moral high ground for other players choosing to play the game differently.

AMERICA.
Last edited by Support#0000 on Oct 3, 2014, 10:34:23 AM
"
Eternallight wrote:
"
Ludvator wrote:
nice post. Id say too good for general discussion

you know, people lie, cheat, scam, doing whatever to gain advantage, be it in RL, or in a game.. Im affraid, no matter what devs do, people will allways find ways..

Im playing for fun only thus I wouldnt need to care too much, but I can immagine how frustrating being an "ethical" competetive player can be


This is exactly the truth, and why I dont try to compete.
I am running a build right now that would never even be in the top 10000 let alone top 100.

I decided to make a build around
.

Its hilarious, I run around with like 150% move speed and get some +300% increased damage. Its not actually anything worthwhile though since all my nodes are +evasion and I have low life and don't want to bother with spending 1000000 ex on mirror worthy gear to make the build op (and even then its not a bow or dagger build... or even crit)


I'm running a dual Dreamfeather/Queen of the Forest build right now in Beyond. I'm level 83 and sailing through content like no tomorrow with 20k dps, 26k dps with pots up. I have 4200 health which is plenty.

If you don't think Dreamfeather is capable of being competitive, you've made a poor build.
Should add back in D2, we had this problem.
I used to play in a pure HC only group, and saw it become tainted by a few players trading in a known website that has bots and people that use hacks like MH. they claimed they were very picky with their trades and never traded with known botters, but ofc can they really fool anyone when every ladder they got endgame runewords? Yeah sure, legit enigma. If you trade in a community full of taint you'll be tainting yourself, hell I know for sure that people in PoE are using that famous website for their needs, you know, the forum gold one.

Its really sad if GGG doesnt try to do more regarding this, Im pretty sure their original stance is against taint.

"
inDef wrote:

My point is, how other people play the game doesn't affect YOUR fun and YOUR style of playing the game. Play the game however the hell you want. But don't come here and claim some imaginary moral high ground for other players choosing to play the game differently.

Actually it does, it taints the economy.

"
Mark_GGG wrote:
In Hardcore, if a character dies, they're out of the league. This doesn't only affect the character, it affects the economy, because all items that character had died with them, and as far as HC is concerned, are gone forever. It is never possible in HC for you to be using an item that belonged to a character that died, because their items were taken out with them.

In Anarchy, characters can continue when they die. While we track character deaths and could move to hardcore only characters that never died in Anarchy, they would be carrying items that do not belong in a hardcore economy, because they've traded with characters who died, and obtained items tainted by death. These characters managed not to die by directly benefiting from a non-HC economy, where far more items are easily available because they aren't constantly leaving, and would carry hundreds of death-tainted items to HC with them, should such a transfer occur.

Even if we kept death counts for every individual item in the league, and didn't transfer those, we'd have characters arriving in hardcore without most of their gear, losing HC gems that were socketed in non-HC items, and fundamentally, we're still putting characters in HC who didn't avoid dying in hardcore.

Not dying in a softcore league and not dying in a hardcore league are not the same, because the softcore league has far more easily available items in the economy, due to them not leaving when characters with them die. It's easier to gear up.
A character who only "didn't die" in Anarchy did not achieve the same as a character who didn't die in HC. They probably used items that wouldn't exist in a hardcore economy. They almost certainly benefited from the larger numbers of items in the economy. If they ever played in parties with characters that died, then they made progress they could not have made in HC.

A character who didn't die in Anarchy, or any other softcore league, is not equivalent to one who doesn't die in hardcore. As such, moving characters from such leagues to hardcore would not be reasonable.
Oblivious
Last edited by Disrupted#3096 on Oct 3, 2014, 1:28:59 PM
"
Swagtrain wrote:
"
Pwnther wrote:

Doesn't that makes you feel so much better knowing you are grown up and don't want/need training wheels to play?

Sure makes me feel better anyways.


You feel like a grown up because of the way you play a video game.

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL


Somebody is getting defensive.
Current IGN: TheBearerOfLight
Gizoogle Chris: "Da State of Exile muthafuckas axed mah crazy ass ta post a reminder dat they podcast is dis weekend, as usual. It aint nuthin but tha nick nack patty wack, I still gots tha bigger sack."
I find my life is much improved if I concern myself with what I am doing rather than what other people are doing.

BTW, big thanks to GGG for the free game.
"
BackwoodsS wrote:
I find my life is much improved if I concern myself with what I am doing rather than what other people are doing.

BTW, big thanks to GGG for the free game.
This is how I feel about most of these situations;

For reference though, I think the problem is not that these things are unethical (not talking about all your examples, but most of them), its that they are not allowed and bannable/probatable offences but GGG can not conclusively prove it in most cases. The only people that can be easily caught out will be streamers really.
i spent a few very boring minutes today - watching a certain streamer who was multi boxing dominus runs.

first off i would like to say watching streamers is about as much fun as [Removed by Support] watching paint dry.

but part of me felt sorry for the said streamer-- if he has to bend/ abuse things ggg did not immediately want to happen in their game and have little power or drive to stop. [Removed by Support]

while i was watching he made a comment about how there was no unique in a huge horde of yellows. and theres the problem. [Removed by Support] complaining about no unique s when ure average player would never say that and be very content when one does appear.

i myself have never used any mods for this game -- not even procurement, and i never will. its just not my style.
i dont even have macros because im a frickin boss who does it old school,, and if i did play hc ( which i dont because my shitty computer/ dysnc really prevents me from doing so) i would never use the logout macro because it is lame and cowardly.
Last edited by Dan_GGG#0000 on Oct 3, 2014, 10:22:04 PM
It scares me when someone decides to do something because the authorities say it's "legal" instead of not doing it because it's just plain wrong.

I do not believe for a moment that most people check their personality traits at the login screen and take on a new persona in game. The way they act in game is largely a reflection of how they act in real life.

A true roleplayer is very a very rare creature.

I used to play a very popular sci-fi MMO based heavily on trading. There are all sorts of trade deals based on trust in that game.

Once in awhile I would see someone say something like "I wouldn't ruin my reputation by stealing such a small amount." I read that comment and I see "I will steal as soon as it becomes lucrative enough."

People are not good at hiding their underlying personality traits.
The "it doesnt effect me so I dont care" mentality is overwhelming here.

Some players find it fun to casually stumble along and go at their own pace, that doesnt mean players that want to be the best are invalid. And we shouldnt have to resort to all the bullshit currently being resorted to if we want to compete.

I also imagine the actually ToU looks more like "Hey guys, could you like, maybe stop that?"
"just for try, for see and for know"
There's very few rules in poe and you'd have to be dumb to get caught breaking most of them.

The odd part is that there is really no prize for being the richest rmt lord or the first to reach 100(in most cases).
IGN: Arlianth
Check out my LA build: 1782214
Last edited by Nephalim#2731 on Oct 6, 2014, 12:11:50 AM

Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info