First Wave of Trade Improvements

"

Schn1tt3r wrote:

oh look! "first wave trade" after 70% of the players lost interest in the game... Also, welcome to pay to win.

I don't care because I have several tabs, but it might be good idea to give everyone one free premium tab at least so the game can be said to still be "free to play"

Looks like a ton of interest to me.

Hi

This is most excellent news minus the premium stash tab part. I wonder if a new vendor that a player could do some quests with to enable him to sell your stuff in each town would've been a better idea as the vendor would not require a premium stash tab but probably wouldn't be able to be accessed outside of the game...which I am aware is something GGG has been striving towards.

After years of playing this game I would highly recommend that GGG gives all players one premium stash tab for free bringing the total to 5 free stash tabs as there is so much more to pick up in the game and then recipes...or I suppose the new mtx packs will have a premium stash tab as part of the deal?

cheers

"

Griide wrote:

People, just dont feed this pay2trolls.

PoE forums really need some moderation.

By moderation you mean removing all criticism of the game? Yeah, that would be definetely a step in a good direction.

"

DemonikPath wrote:

"

GeorgAnatoly wrote:

Ignore the haters GGG. I knew anything you rolled out that would improve trade would cause a shit storm. The amount of p2w here is very reasonable and ethical.

Where is the line between ethical and reasonable p2w and not?
Would it be ethical if GGG offered:
- Increased chance to get high tier map drops for 1 month?
- Increased XP gain for 1 month?
- In-game currency for real money?

PoE is already in a grey zone with it's stash space, but as long as TOS permits use of mule accounts it's not really a P2W in any way (in D2 it was the only way to have a lot of stash space).
But in this case they are gating core gameplay behind a paywall, and those who don't have premium tabs can only hope that Xyz nor GGG doesn't drop support for forum trading (which is a terrible system) and are always at risk of their accounts being compromised (e.g. someone hacks Xyz github account and publishes new Aquisition release that steals you account data etc.). And if people are fine with this, why not make people pay for some other core gameplay systems? Let's say they recently removed some leagues from Zana, why not make MTX - unlock all past leagues in Zana map device?

I get why people are up in arms about this. It's gating a portion of the game behind money and they've only ever done that with stash space, it's completely understandable.

Admittedly unless their intention was to prevent bot accounts from having easy access to this feature I'm not sure what their motive was for gating it behind money. I really doubt profit was the principle objective, which is why I am of the position that people are over reacting to it.

I thought about this new trade "improvement" system.
My questions are:
- why this can not work on any tabs, so ppl with premium, and normal stash could use this feature? Only difference would be that premium stash users could name their tabs to, let say, "Shop Stuff"

-If all the 3rd party programs will still be usable (I use procurement personally), what will happen when the authors of this and the other trading program will decide to pull out and stop their support?
As far as i can see this will indeed brings pay2trade (aka p2w) situations, where some players will be privilege to trade while others will only be confided to self-found or spam channels....ehmm, I mean trade channels, in game.

Not everyone can spend monies on the game, or supporter packs or any micro transactions, for some these dollars are a weeks or more wages, seeing many post here saying "Oh, just throw few bucks and you will be fine" is not a solution in a free to play game, where devs clearly admitted they do not want give advantage to others by the way of micro transactions.

I don't like the trading improvements much actually. As a buyer I would like something that allowed me to browse all the offered items (public, in-game) and that provided an automatic transaction system. I don't sell items at all, I like to play the time I'm online

That said, I don't understand all the P2W fuss. The game is free to play, it has weekly updates and several major versions each year, it's great overall. GGG is a company and needs money to operate. It seems to me that people don't realize that other players are actually paying. Their F2P is only achieved by the continuous support of others. I'm ashamed to see people who don't contibute a dime complaining loudly, asking for more, always more and gratis

"

GeorgAnatoly wrote:

Admittedly unless their intention was to prevent bot accounts from having easy access to this feature I'm not sure what their motive was for gating it behind money. I really doubt profit was the principle objective, which is why I am of the position that people are over reacting to it.

As I said above possible motive was to prevent abuse of the system in first few days of the league. Let's say everyone just makes public tab and constantly moves items in/out of tab (it's not unusual in first days of the league), with a lot of new & returning players with the expansion it will make API feed updates HUGE. So they probably decided to restrict it to premium tabs because of that without thinking about possible backlash.
Second reason is hacky system they use for full tab price, that uses tab name for storing price (which is stupid imo).

To quote jim raynor Hail to the king, baby! uuuh not Duke Nukem i mean, Hell it's about time

It is an essential functionality, about something that was missing and promised for a long time, behind a pay wall.

The fact that there are third party programs available is IRRELEVANT because these might or might not exist as far as GGG is concerned. They do not have the luxury of presenting what the community has voluntarily done to fix their game as a valid alternative. ESPECIALLY if they themselves have these or similar features behind a paywall.

Imo it is NEVER acceptable to rely on the community to do your job (or a better one).

This is clearly saying "In-game shop management is for premium members", which is a first for PoE. There was never anything that couldn't be, in a worst case scenario, resolved by having another account (for additional stash space or characters).

Now there is. This is a troubling step and defending it mindlessly with ridiculous arguments like "it could be worse" or "GGG doesn't owe anything" is nothing more than encouragement to potentially push it further in the future.

GGG This is a very good improvement and I congratulate you for this. I was usually too lazy to update procurement and post the trade text. This is so much welcomed.

One think bothers me, there is too much hate about this "only premium tab", I personally don't care because I got more than 50 premium stash tabs. But please just make them happy an give them at least one or two premium tabs to start off with. They will be happy "hopefully", but what's more important, this will be an incentive for people which didn't buy any premium tabs. I guarantee you, after they start to use the premium tab they will also start buying new ones. You can actually make a statistics of stash tab purchase after this update.

Cheers.