Looting -- The official thread for discussing the loot system. Updated 18th March, 2013.

"

davidkain wrote:

My two cents, as a brand new player to this game, but a veteran of many others.

I think the option to choose your loot style when creating a public party in the default league can only help the game. For more tense leagues, remove this option. This satisfies the desire of some players for an alternative to FFA, while still allowing GGG to up the ante in competitive play.

Alternatively, create a casual league with unique loot rules. The key is player choice, which is lacking in the current implementation.

I really like the idea of league controlled loot options. Best compromise so far!
A cut throat league with random groups and full FFA loot would be a rush.

1.Game is currently in beta. Any accumulated wealth will disappear in a little over a month.

2.My concern is with new players and the overall health of a game that I am beta testing.

3.This debate is useful because Davidkain just provided a unique idea that would improve the game.

One of the biggest issues with the current system is that it DOES cater to people who don’t want to share.

I ‘like’ the rest of game why should I not ‘like’ the co-op experience?

"

SMRD wrote:

"

iamstryker wrote:

"

wrathmar wrote:

So what is the point of having cosmetic pets, player skins, alternate spell animations… when a significant portion of the game population avoids co-op?

This has been one of my biggest concerns from the start. I would be interested in buying that stuff if I played public games more often. Its possible I might change my mind down the road but at the moment I just don't like public games enough to spend currency on flashy cool looking cosmetics. If I didn't have to deal with FFA loot I would be in there nearly every play session.

#1 lots of people play co-op, just not public games.

#2 so you’re SO poor you can’t deal with co-op loot because you MIGHT lose something out to a stranger. Really? you just can’t take that risk eh? I guess that is our loss.

#3 many people get invited to private games by looking for a group in global chat or local chat.

I just can’t stand this topic any more. Everything has been said over and over again repeatedly.

The loot system functions as designed, it is not an oversight or mistake, you are not expected to "like" it. Playing in a party is a shared experience. Just because some people can’t handle sharing does not mean the game should be made to cater to them.

There are no “options” that could be added that would not ultimately be applied to everyone.

lol cant stand this topic anymore? wait till open beta. this will be mild compared to then :)

"

SMRD wrote:

#1 lots of people play co-op, just not public games.

Of course they do, but lots of people DON'T play public which is a big part of showing off your cosmetics. Ya I can buy stuff to show off to the people on my friends list but It would beven cooler if I hoped in and out of public games. Thats my point. Its irrefutable because I am talking about myself. I suspect that's how a lot of people will feel.

"

SMRD wrote:

#2 so you’re SO poor you can’t deal with co-op loot because you MIGHT lose something out to a stranger. Really? you just can’t take that risk eh? I guess that is our loss.

Way to rehash the same argument again SMRD cudos. I happen to be poor enough that losing out on a good orb is irritating, but beyond that I don't enjoy PVP when I am trying to play pure PVE. That is my opinion and it appears to be the opinion of a lot of players. Ya really, not everyone can play this game so much that all orbs aren't that big of a deal anymore. I don't know if I will ever have 50 gcp in my stash. Maybe someday.

"

SMRD wrote:

#3 many people get invited to private games by looking for a group in global chat or local chat.

I'm not arguing that they don't

"

SMRD wrote:

I just can’t stand this topic any more. Everything has been said over and over again repeatedly.

Then don't participate?

"

SMRD wrote:

The loot system functions as designed, it is not an oversight or mistake, you are not expected to "like" it.

Of course it is. I hope GGG doesn't keep putting in features that people don't like. I kind of hope the game gets really popular. My biggest gripe with not liking FFA is that I don't see the payoff to the game for having it like this. Doesn't seem worth it at all.

"

SMRD wrote:

Playing in a party is a shared experience. Just because some people can’t handle sharing does not mean the game should be made to cater to them.

Again, this isn't the point at all. People like myself who don't like FFA are generally very generous. I gave away some stuff today to a guy I met in general chat. You don't understand my perspective and I don't fully understand yours, oh well thats life. Don't try to put us down just because you don't get it. I share fine, I don't want to compete.

"

SMRD wrote:

There are no “options” that could be added that would not ultimately be applied to everyone.

Thats your opinion that can't really be proven without a test. But if absolutely everyone stays out of FFA at that point and there are more public games then its totally worth it from my perspective. Cutthroat leagues with FFA would still exist.

"

SMRD wrote:

The loot system functions as designed, it is not an oversight or mistake, you are not expected to "like" it. Playing in a party is a shared experience. Just because some people can’t handle sharing does not mean the game should be made to cater to them.

There are no “options” that could be added that would not ultimately be applied to everyone.

Then the design of the loot system is shit. If I'm not supposed to like it, I will naturally avoid it - and that's what I'm doing.
And please don't say "some people can't handle it", it is the majority. I'm very open to a poll on the PoE page to clarify this once and for all.

"

#2 so you’re SO poor you can’t deal with co-op loot because you MIGHT lose something out to a stranger. Really? you just can’t take that risk eh? I guess that is our loss.

Sorry if I'm not 15 anymore and have countless hours for gaming. If I play a game I want to make progress and have fun, not getting frustrated because someone ninjas the loot and makes me keep looking for different groups.

Sorry if I sound rude, but I'm as annoyed as you are, everything has been said over and over again.

"

SMRD wrote:

3. This suggestion has been brought up many times. It was referred to as "candy land league" and personally, I do not care one way or the other, but say goodbye to a huge chunk of the player base that would never try the full game.

If a huge chunk of the player base would want to play that league then they should have the option to do so. The idea that they wouldn't be playing the full game is really dumb. The game already has a bunch of players who aren't playing this so called "full game".

"

SMRD wrote:

I like the rest of the game too, and would argue that without ffa loot the entire game would be slower pace - less exciting and ultimately most people would have no reason to make friends/guilds/traveling buddies and have less respect for their fellow gamer or their own reputations.

All of that is personal opinion. Not to mention how many players enjoy playing slower paced. Since when does everyone have to play super fast? I don't like FFA and I still want to make friends, join guilds, have traveling buddies.

"

SMRD wrote:

"

davidkain wrote:

Alternatively, create a casual league with unique loot rules. The key is player choice, which is lacking in the current implementation.

3. This suggestion has been brought up many times. It was referred to as "candy land league" and personally, I do not care one way or the other, but say goodbye to a huge chunk of the player base that would never try the full game.

I streamlined this quote so it makes a bit more sense to people only reading the newest replies.

Anyway, I don't know what the previous suggestion entailed, but even if it did affect more than the looting rules, does it matter? The hardcore league is exactly the same except death is permanent in a sense, what's wrong with going in the opposite direction?

Regarding population, you can again look to the population of the hardcore league vs. the default one. I don't have those numbers obviously, but hardcore doesn't seem to exactly be lacking in players. In fact, if the majority of the playerbase did play on this league, it would probably be almost entirely be populated not by those who currently enjoy the game, but by those wouldn't have enjoyed playing it otherwise.

In fact, the concept of different "leagues" within the same game is fairly revolutionary. How many people would have stuck with Diablo 3 if there was a 'Increased Drop Rate with Restricted/Disabled Trading League'? Or even a multiplayer only league with nerfed monster damage/health/loot but with open hostility and full loot on death? Obviously not entirely born by Grinding Gear, since D2's hardcore ladders and such were entirely separated, and I'm sure there are other examples in games before that, but it's never been quite as integral as it is in this game.

Regardless, I'm not advocating a difficulty decrease or anything, I don't think it's either desired or needed. I just want to be able to enjoy a multiplayer experience where loot is a secondary focus, (sometimes I do this anyway, since I can usually go a while on only blue loot and wisdom scrolls) whether that's through a league or not.

The only reason I would be against varied loot rules is because of one time where I solo killed a few enemies away from the group and a Gemcutter's Prism dropped for someone else. He came running over when I told him it dropped for him though, and I suppose it would have been his loss and not mine, haha.

Damn, I must feel pretty strongly about this topic since I almost never type this much.

The biggest problem i see in this thread is: the guys who love and advocate the FFA loot system are looking like elitist jerks. Please don´t take it personal.

If you like it, simple point why do you like, don´t try sound like a elitist saying crap like: "you can´t afford lose one item? NOOB! Burn in the noobland". It make you look like a 12 year spoiled kid.

You guys have your opinion in the loot system, and i respect it. But i don´t agree with it. But, because i dont agree with you im not allowed to say you are noobs without time to play the game for an entire day or multi-box all day long and stuff . . .

We are lacking respect in here. Let´s keep an polite atitude towards each other.