Thanks for trying GGG. After about 20k hours in POE 1, POE 2 just is not it.

"
theoc86#4909 wrote:
If the developers want to make a very different game, then bravo to them, win or lose its a positive for the games industry which may hopefully inspire others to actually stop milking customers and make new games rather than the same thing over and over.


If they want to make a Different game, woulda been best to not call it PoE2 cause, that usually implies it's a sequel, which would mean I'd expect similar things. This is a Dark Souls clone missing all the good things from Dark Souls and PoE. I got to cruel and it's just boring. Monster Hunter, Elden Ring, Dark Souls, Bloodborne, all do what PoE2 desperately wants to, better in every way.
"

What do you mean when you say it wasn’t promised?
How is cherry-picking relevant here? Did I claim that everyone does it this way? No, I didn’t. I pointed to successful examples of two massively popular online games (except Civ) whose developers respected the old fanbase that supported them for ten years. Meanwhile, you brought up three games, two of which are niche console titles, and the third suffered heavily from a similar transition. Fallout 1 and 2 were brilliant, Tactics was decent, but the franchise lost its way in trying to cater to consoles and the masses. Not the best comparison, honestly.

I wasn’t expecting anything different. I’m just disappointed that this direction will likely harm a game I love, that’s all. Do you think I’m here because I couldn’t handle the first boss? I didn’t even buy the starter pack, saying from the start that this wasn’t for me.


It wasnt promised means what it means, it just wasnt. You call Mass Effect niche? The best to date Fallout is New Vegas thats has nothing from the original gameplay wise. Mass Effect 2 is regarded as the best in frenchise. Dota 2 is actually the first one since Dota was just a mod, that I would call bad comparison.

You knew for like what? 3 years? That PoE2 will be new game and not just upgrade for PoE1. What harm you talk about? PoE1 isnt going anywhere. PoE2 doesnt affect the first one in the slightest. You are here because you prefer walking simulator over engaging fights. I hope that answered your questions.
"

If they want to make a Different game, woulda been best to not call it PoE2


i agree.

if you go that different, it should be a new IP.

it's not that it's bad.. it's that i dont feel like im playing a poe game.


also weird that chris eric and jonathan arnt shareholders at all anymore, interesting timing.
100% tencent now according to that "New Zealand Companies Office" website.
Last edited by teksuoPOE#2987 on Dec 9, 2024, 11:58:28 AM
The Soul’s crowd won’t stick around once they’ve beaten the game. They’re off to the next challenge. They don’t want to grind another character, they want a new challenge. So who’s going to be left playing this game in a year or two? The same people who got you here. Not the souls crowd. hope they wake up and realize that before it gets too late.
I can play the game, I can get through the zones, I can beat the bosses, But it's just not fun..

I personally play Arpg's for Loot, Loot is my addiction lol, it's why I have 100 stash tabs in POE1 haha I am a loot hoarder. and there is just no loot in poe2

and my character never feels strong, it's just not fun to me.

I am happy for those who are enjoying it, but I would not go back and play a league if it stays the same as it is right now.
"
Smhtwo#2862 wrote:
. They don’t want to grind another character...


I don't even want to bother grinding a new character for how much of a tedious slog the campaign was. In PoE1 repeating the campaign wasn't an issue cause I spent time learning how to do it fast and it was at best 10 hours, this just isn't true here and you don't even get access to half the skill till lv 40 so I will pretty much be repeating the same few handful of leveling builds over and over if I make a new one.

Also with crucial upgrades being scattered around a mostly empty map in terms of stuff to "explore" I wonder why the maps are as large as they are as it adds nothing but a tedious commute that now respawns if you die to a random rare mob you didn't know was rare cause there is no outlines.

No real motivation to keep playing, beat the acts, playing in cruel, same old tedium.
"
VSwift#7054 wrote:
It's shocking these people can't accept change and developing a game series

They just want the same game with updated visuals.

Guess what you're not getting it. See you!



Lets wait first. POE1 wouldnt be the first game surviving its successor.
It will be interesting to see if POE1 or POE2 gets more people to return every 3-4 months. If POE1 remains the fanfavourite it could get "visual updates" and finally more devtime again.

It could be them changing poe2 more to be like poe1. But maybe there are enough people enjoying poe2. Time will tell.
Last edited by camar1s#6601 on Dec 9, 2024, 2:19:50 PM
"
"
theoc86#4909 wrote:
If the developers want to make a very different game, then bravo to them, win or lose its a positive for the games industry which may hopefully inspire others to actually stop milking customers and make new games rather than the same thing over and over.


If they want to make a Different game, woulda been best to not call it PoE2 cause, that usually implies it's a sequel, which would mean I'd expect similar things.
Your expectations are not GGG's responsibility.
I, for one, don't like pressing too many buttons. That doesn't make me unskilled, lazy, complacent or whatever other descriptor you are trying to pluck from your vocabulary. - Unknown philosopher, ca. 2025
"
Ulsarek#7159 wrote:
"
"
theoc86#4909 wrote:
If the developers want to make a very different game, then bravo to them, win or lose its a positive for the games industry which may hopefully inspire others to actually stop milking customers and make new games rather than the same thing over and over.


If they want to make a Different game, woulda been best to not call it PoE2 cause, that usually implies it's a sequel, which would mean I'd expect similar things.
Your expectations are not GGG's responsibility.


Pretty brain dead response. I fail to see how it is illogical to assume a sequel would be relevant to the first one. Devs are just desperately wanting to make a FromSoft game but are forever shackled to an ARPG. Thing is it's pretty weak as far as souls games go.
"
kuciol#0426 wrote:
"

What do you mean when you say it wasn’t promised?
How is cherry-picking relevant here? Did I claim that everyone does it this way? No, I didn’t. I pointed to successful examples of two massively popular online games (except Civ) whose developers respected the old fanbase that supported them for ten years. Meanwhile, you brought up three games, two of which are niche console titles, and the third suffered heavily from a similar transition. Fallout 1 and 2 were brilliant, Tactics was decent, but the franchise lost its way in trying to cater to consoles and the masses. Not the best comparison, honestly.

I wasn’t expecting anything different. I’m just disappointed that this direction will likely harm a game I love, that’s all. Do you think I’m here because I couldn’t handle the first boss? I didn’t even buy the starter pack, saying from the start that this wasn’t for me.


It wasnt promised means what it means, it just wasnt. You call Mass Effect niche? The best to date Fallout is New Vegas thats has nothing from the original gameplay wise. Mass Effect 2 is regarded as the best in frenchise. Dota 2 is actually the first one since Dota was just a mod, that I would call bad comparison.

You knew for like what? 3 years? That PoE2 will be new game and not just upgrade for PoE1. What harm you talk about? PoE1 isnt going anywhere. PoE2 doesnt affect the first one in the slightest. You are here because you prefer walking simulator over engaging fights. I hope that answered your questions.
You might be right. We're arguing about subjective matters. Not the best way to have a constructive dialogue.

Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info