FIX THE SUDDEN SHUT DOWNS!!!!!!!!!!

Ok to start this thread off, if anyone says it's an overheating problem am going to track them down and throw them off a cliff, for reals.

Now to the problem! So I'm playing PoE (which is amazing) and all of a sudden... BOOM!!! Shuts my entire computer down! No BSOD no nothing! Just like your getting knocked out. No weird sounds! NUTTIN! This happens to me at least 4-5 times a day.

Note: This usually only happens in parties. I can play solo with no problems. When I play in parties this generally happens in Docks but has happened in maps and Lunaris ETC. I think Docks has intense particles with the rain and all but it shouldn't be causing shut downs.

This problem already has multiple threads but they all suck. Most of them have people replying they have the same problem or people saying it's overheating. IT"S NOT OVERHEATING! Most of the people who have this problem are running on high end machines and the temps are normal.

I am using a Samsung RF711 Laptop with a I7 Intel Processor and a GT 540M. Now I understand the GPU isn't the best but I have run at least 100 hours of BF3 and Diablo 3 on this thing with ablsolutely NO ISSUES AT ALL! Flawless! So that leaves one conclusion... this game is at fault. There's no way it has anything to do with my computers hardware. It only happens in Poe and has NEVER EVER happened in any other game.

I have tried everything!!! I'll make a list!

1. Tried the creative sound card edit
2. Have turned down graphics ALOT!!!(even put the production config file texture settings to 5!)
3. Using Bandicam to limit FPS to 30
4. Changed laptop battery settings
5. Tried every V SYNC fix there is. Turned on in game, even forced in my Nvidia Control Pannel
6. Graphics Drivers are up to date!!!

Nothing has even remotely worked. The only thing that seems to help is to warm the game up. If I play solo for a bit then transition into a party I can play up to an hour or more without a crash. Although I should be able to jump into a party and farm docks with no issues at all.

The only dev post I have seen is this.

"Technically the game itself can't cause your PC to shut down, so I'd check that your drivers are up to date, and maybe using something like SpeedFan to check that the PC isn't reaching unreasonable temperatures! If he has a Creative sound card, you may want to look at the relevant thread in this forum."

WTF... really! First off yes it is the game itself causing the shut down. I am not going to dis the devs but really!? You guys need to make a solid RUNNING game rather than releasing new gems each week. Secondly lets face it! 90% of the people complaining about this issue are people who know their shit. They know how to update drivers and check temps! So don't even bother telling us that any more. The sounds card advice is the only good advice they wrote!

For those of you who read this, Thanks. I don't want to sound pissed of by writing all this just want to make it clear how frustrating it is to not be able to enjoy a great game.

Lil Sebastian
I hate to say this, but being a developer myself I know that there is little the game itself can directly do to cause your PC to shut down. however, what the game CAN do to cause it to shut down is to exaggerate an issue your PC already had.

What I mean by this is if something in the hardware is possibly unstable or prone to failure, the game can cause it to go beyond normal ranges and crash.

You also cannot compare other games like BF3 to this game. Although a lot of people try, it's not a valid comparison. Each game is different and behaves differently of different hardware. you can run one game without any issue and find that a different one won't run at all.

I'm not saying that you are overheating, but something in your hardware or drivers doesn't sound stable and it's possible that this game is exposing that.
Thanks for the response! How do I diagnose my problem? And I understand that games behave differently it's just very hard to understand why a insanely graphical game like BF3 will run great and PoE is full of shut downs. I do understand it is in beta though!
Lil Sebastian
I'd start with some decent monitoring software that can log considering it's rebooting it would be hard to get the results otherwise.

there are also other programs that can stress each component of your PC to see if it can crash that way.

but I'd start with monitors. both for temperatures as well as load and voltages.

hopefully one of those will give you a workable result.
"
Drakier wrote:
I'd start with some decent monitoring software that can log considering it's rebooting it would be hard to get the results otherwise.

there are also other programs that can stress each component of your PC to see if it can crash that way.

but I'd start with monitors. both for temperatures as well as load and voltages.

hopefully one of those will give you a workable result.


Sry to say that, but that's bs (just like your post in the other thread).
You sound like one of those Hotline ppl that state the obvious but without any useful information whatsoever.
It's pretty easy to crash any computer with a few lines of code. If you're saying that's a problem within the hardware that makes your PC crash with my lines of code, that's kinda wrong. I feed smth to the PC that can't be processed, who's fault is that? It's like saying the kitchen sucks if the guest doesn't like the kitchen (although the kitchen is a Michelin Star one).
Of course the bsod is triggered by sources outside the game, like ati3duag.dll and stuff, but it's caused by the game expecting a response that's not possible.

@OP
The reason your PC just reboots is cause it's set to reboot on serious errors without showing the bsod first. This can easily be deactivated.
Nervertheless Windows creates minidumps including the bsod crashreports. These can be read with (for example) WhoCrashed.
I've talked to Rory about this and he verified, that their tech is working on fixing it, he was very thankfull for the minidumps i provided, and i suggest you start there too, by sending them these. It's the most usefull thing you can do at this point.

IGN: Darkrox (not my main, just for easy contact)
~ Yes i'm the Darkrox from Runes of Magic - World's #1 Guild Pravum 2009 - 2011 ~
Last edited by Darkrox#0968 on Apr 16, 2013, 4:59:48 AM
"
Darkrox01 wrote:

Sry to say that, but that's bs (just like your post in the other thread).
You sound like one of those Hotline ppl that state the obvious but without any useful information whatsoever.
It's pretty easy to crash any computer with a few lines of code. If you're saying that's a problem within the hardware that makes your PC crash with my lines of code, that's kinda wrong. I feed smth to the PC that can't be processed, who's fault is that? It's like saying the kitchen sucks if the guest doesn't like the kitchen (although the kitchen is a Michelin Star one).
Of course the bsod is triggered by sources outside the game, like ati3duag.dll and stuff, but it's caused by the game expecting a response that's not possible.

@OP
The reason your PC just reboots is cause it's set to reboot on serious errors without showing the bsod first. This can easily be deactivated.
Nervertheless Windows creates minidumps including the bsod crashreports. These can be read with (for example) WhoCrashed.
I've talked to Rory about this and he verified, that their tech is working on fixing it, he was very thankfull for the minidumps i provided, and i suggest you start there too, by sending them these. It's the most usefull thing you can do at this point.


Darkrox01: There's no need for that. We're all just trying to help people here. And it's not like I'm making comments that could hurt his PC or are of absolutely no use. Also, if you'll read the "other thread" you are referring to, you'll understand that what I said is not "bs". Just you don't understand what it was I was talking about.

Also.. feeding something to the PC that can't be processed is not something that is common within this game, and that was the context of my statement. Generally, it is not something that is possible to just crash a PC with normal software unless there is a driver/hardware misbehaving... especially as it relates to BSOD or any other sudden crash. It just doesn't happen. I'm not saying you can't MAKE something with the sole intention of crashing a PC. That's not within the context of the post. The post is that his PC is crashing while running PoE, and there is nothing within PoE itself that could cause that behavior.
"
Chewy948 wrote:
IT"S NOT OVERHEATING!


"
Drakier wrote:
but I'd start with monitors. both for temperatures as well as load and voltages.


"
Drakier wrote:
And it's not like I'm making comments that [...] are of absolutely no use.


Well...I see that differently.

And as stated, it's not PoE itself that causes the bsod, but it triggers the exception. It's not like the graphics card randomly says: "Ah well, i don't like that request, i'll simply not progress that", but i've said that already.
It's not a hardware flaw, since other games can work within the limitations of hardware and not simply break thorugh, causing a bluescreen.

I'll also take the freedom to reply to the other thread here:
Particle systems, no matter if selfmade or licenced, have the same flaw, they performe poorly if the Artists are given free hand with the design of the effects.
I bet Poison Arrow looked awesome in Cinema4D. But using 1 million particles emitted at once from a tiny little arrow wont work in a game when 5 other people do the same at once. And considering the fact that even people with the newest generation of gpu report fps drops in these situations proof, that no current gpu has enough compute shaders to handle the amount used.
Simple solution is reducing the freaking amount of particles, which is a very easy task to accomplish.
IGN: Darkrox (not my main, just for easy contact)
~ Yes i'm the Darkrox from Runes of Magic - World's #1 Guild Pravum 2009 - 2011 ~
I'm not here to argue with you. I'm here to provide assistance.

I suggested the user run monitors not only for temperature but also for load and voltage.

Depending on the type of crash (and neither of us know the actual crash that's happening yet as the user has not said it) it could be due to a lot of things. All we know is the user is rebooting. That could be due to the auto-reboot on the BSOD (which I doubt because even with the auto-reboot, it isn't usually instant, and you get a glimpse of a blue error screen), or it could be due to the hardware just causing a restart.

The reason I bring up load and voltage specifically is I had a machine of my own that the PSU was under-rated for the hardware I was running. I didn't realize it at the time until I put my machine under some heavy load (playing PoE). My machine started rebooting.. very similarly to the report here. After some diagnostics, I found out that the PSU was being over-drawn and causing low voltage to the MB. This caused the PC to randomly reboot itself. No errors. No BSOD (I was on Linux, so that doesn't happen), but it just rebooted.

There's a reason I make these suggestions. I have experience with them. I'm not saying your suggestions are invalid. In fact, you brought up a suggestion I didn't think of (the auto-reboot enabled on BSOD).

What it comes down to here is that I'm not going after you and trying to knock down all your suggestions, or say that you're offering "BS" or anything of the sort. I'm trying to help a user get PoE working on their machine properly. I'm checking all the angles I can think of. Since I had an exact same problem on my PC, I figured it was worth checking out on his.

So can we please stop with the name-calling, bickering, belittling, and arguing... and get back to helping users play this awesome game?
The thing is, i'm having the same problem as OP, and wasn't able to fix it, let's call it "client-sided".
Since a lot of players report that kind of PC behavoir it's the most obvious assumption, that he got the same problem as everyone else, except he get's no bsod. That's why i brought the auto-reboot up and suggested reading out the minidumps to back up my hypothesis.

That's also the reason why i ruled out the overheat and load thesis, since i checked that on my PC and since OP said he checked heat too. Gpus with high load rise in temp pretty fast, so both stick together most of the time, so cheking either of both should be enough imo.

I'm not saying that Voltage for example can't be the reason. Some time ago my PC started rebooting or shutting down at random too, and the reason was the Powersupply since the new gpu drained far too much for it at full load. But this brings us back to temp and load, if they aren't high, it's most likely not draining full power (atleast mine clocks down depending on load) + OP can play BF without problems and i'm pretty sure that takes 100% cpu and gpu.

To sum up this wall of text: I'm pretty sure the user is having the same bsod problem as everyone else, and therefore there is no solution atm besides providing GGG with the crash infos.

Sidenode btw: The bsod on AMD cards is triggered by ati3duag.dll, but Nvidia users are getting the bsod too, would be good to know what triggers the bsod for them. So in case any Nvidia user or even OP is reading this, let us and GGG know what causes it for you.

btw: Sry if i seem grumpy, it's kind of my job to argue and that's hard to suppress in my freetime =)
IGN: Darkrox (not my main, just for easy contact)
~ Yes i'm the Darkrox from Runes of Magic - World's #1 Guild Pravum 2009 - 2011 ~
Last edited by Darkrox#0968 on Apr 16, 2013, 1:22:25 PM
I understand. It's all good. We're all after the same thing here.

Your stuff is probably easier to check for the user, so I'd suggest he try it. Try disabling the auto-reboot on error thing, and see if a BSOD is being produced. If so, we'll know that is the case and can lay it to rest as most likely the same cause.

While it's not a great solution at this point, at least we'd know what was going on and could stop really searching for the cause of the problem.

In the case it isn't producing a BSOD and just rebooting itself without error, I'd like some information from the monitors to see if you're having similar voltage problems. The fact that it's a laptop makes it a little harder in the case that you can't just easily replace the PSU like a desktop... but the information could be useful in that case still.

Hope it can be easily figured out.

Good luck and cheers mate.

Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info