Daggers.. #1 in dps... #1 in crit... #1 in passive tree... am I missing something?

Shadow and his daggers are one of the lovely things in this game imo
next is crit puncture archer ranger :) but if GGG ruin them what will be so nice then? the weak witches or desync cyclone 2H marauders? maybe the boring, but tanky facebreaker duelist -_-
"
njohnson wrote:
I don't understand why people complain about things being overpowered. If they are so what, play something that suits you. What does it matter what someone else's build is?


have you ever played in a group or with friends and found out that you were slowing them down and that they would be better off dropping your ass like a sack of potatoes?

Because that is what everyone else is to a crit build . a sack of potatoes slowing them down.

I mean if you dont play with friends , then sure that is fine... but then why are you playing a multiplayer game?
"
Saltychipmunk wrote:
"
njohnson wrote:
I don't understand why people complain about things being overpowered. If they are so what, play something that suits you. What does it matter what someone else's build is?


have you ever played in a group or with friends and found out that you were slowing them down and that they would be better off dropping your ass like a sack of potatoes?

Because that is what everyone else is to a crit build . a sack of potatoes slowing them down.

I mean if you dont play with friends , then sure that is fine... but then why are you playing a multiplayer game?


so what are you saying ? play crit or don't play PoE ?

build diversity !
"
plasticeyes wrote:
"
Saltychipmunk wrote:
"
njohnson wrote:
I don't understand why people complain about things being overpowered. If they are so what, play something that suits you. What does it matter what someone else's build is?


have you ever played in a group or with friends and found out that you were slowing them down and that they would be better off dropping your ass like a sack of potatoes?

Because that is what everyone else is to a crit build . a sack of potatoes slowing them down.

I mean if you dont play with friends , then sure that is fine... but then why are you playing a multiplayer game?


so what are you saying ? play crit or don't play PoE ?

build diversity !


I mapped a lot with an arc-witch in 1.1. with my low-life st build and for sure I was faster, but not that much...
And some people enjoy slower builds... but for me its impossible to play something else, than crit-dagger... but I'm changing the stuff behind (flicker ci, st low-ife, block life) ^^
"
plasticeyes wrote:
"
Saltychipmunk wrote:
"
njohnson wrote:
I don't understand why people complain about things being overpowered. If they are so what, play something that suits you. What does it matter what someone else's build is?


have you ever played in a group or with friends and found out that you were slowing them down and that they would be better off dropping your ass like a sack of potatoes?

Because that is what everyone else is to a crit build . a sack of potatoes slowing them down.

I mean if you dont play with friends , then sure that is fine... but then why are you playing a multiplayer game?


so what are you saying ? play crit or don't play PoE ?

build diversity !


ugh why do you people keep missing the point , i am not saying that dagger is the >only< way to go, i am saying that dagger is clearly the >best< way to go. as in you get way more bang for you buck.

do you not want those other builds to have a power ceiling closer to daggers? because that is what you and those like you are communicating to me by saying nothing.

there are many fun builds out there . but that doesn't mean they are perfect and should not be changed.

I am lobbying for those builds.


crit is a balance issue , it has always been a balance issue. we need to stop kicking it under the rug
Last edited by Saltychipmunk#1430 on Aug 25, 2014, 3:35:02 PM
"
Saltychipmunk wrote:
I tried to give two hander an honest shot this league. got to level 70 in 3 days

i do 19k dps double strikes 10k cleaves and 7k leap slams (all 4l) on a 340dps 2 hander

7 frenzy charges.

(btw frenzy with 7 frenzy charges does 2k less than double strike ... hey ggg that's fucked up)

then i meet a guy with two ungis gultch daggers doing 25k dps double strikes with melee splash. and im like .. what the hell?

he then told me he was using them as a joke and his real build is a 40k dps molten strike with a 170k dps dagger and a perandus shield .

all the while im like why did i make a 2 hander build.

I know for a fact that my 2 hander build wont be map capable just on the fact that i cant stack enough defenses to make up for the loss of that free block , life , resists and armor/es/evasion on a shield .

and now im farming docks for masters while leveling a summoner on an alt account in which the bloody zombies will have 70 block chance with bone offering and 3 timez my hp pool.

and that is one zombie.

2 handers are in a bad spot. and daggers are ridiculous all crit weapons are. everyone i know is rolling crit.

even my mate who is building a bow build .. is using a dagger to level up ... what .. the heck is that?


It is a ridiculous situation that ggg obviously didn't want to address. Its been discussed in feedback/suggestions forums eternally before the patch.
"
Saltychipmunk wrote:

crit is a balance issue , it has always been a balance issue. we need to stop kicking it under the rug

I agree.

Honestly, you could nearly half the flat damage of all daggers and they would still be very powerful. Daggers should have half the flat damage potential of other 1h variants, but twice the crit chance. Now they have the same flat damage but still twice the crit chance.
"
missuse wrote:


I have a clan mate that has a mirrored 2h axe. He is using it in a RT build. He sits at 69k cyclone. I have a mirrored dagger and my reave is 140 k with auras. We both have very high survivability. Guess what, when we map he clears most shit before I get my reave charges up.

Ive bought my former diamond rings from a guy who had one of the best crit/staff builds. He had over 120k cyclone which is almost double than Tommy (my before mentioned clan mate has).

What numbers should I run? I posted two builds, a fully optimized dagger life build with block and the first crit stave build I could come up with 180% life. Check them out. Do number crunching, I am sure the stave will be at least at 820/560 = 1,46 more dps compared to daggers with those builds. DPS is not the issue, its the fact that in the Atziri patch everyone copied dagger ST low life builds since they could run high dps and a lot of auras and obliterate uber.


Except you completely disregarded the fact that the dagger build has close to 50% higher IAS from the tree AND has a good >100% crit multi over the staff. You're telling me to check out numbers you posted that I already told you were wrong. The numbers do NOT support your argument. I am telling *YOU* to look at them because the daggers are dealing MORE damage. No, the staff is NOT dealing 46% more damage than the dagger - that's just the baseline per hit. It's quite the opposite in fact - if you take crit multi and IAS into account then (without gear critmulti or IAS) then daggers are dealing a good 70% more damage than staves.

Then on top your story compares two skills which have nothing to do with this. You say you have double his DPS but he clears things faster because he hits them? Have you tried using a different skill also?
@Aelloon
I think I can get behind the concept of daggers being overpowered. Maybe not as drastically as some suggest, but I can see the math of the tree, and the mods daggers can get, and I can see the inherent power.

That being said, are we suggesting daggers be nerfed, or that 2h be buffed? I'm thinking a combination of both could be the best route. That way the changes can be smaller. Very small nerf to daggers, so people using daggers don't lose their minds, and a small buff to 2h, so people who want to use 2h builds can feel a bit better they aren't just shooting themselves in the foot by doing so.

I think ( and it may just be me ) that the larger the change to 2h or dagger, the more people will get upset.
"I would have listened... I would have understood!" - Scion

Have you removed Asus ROG/GameFirst yet?
Well yeh, none of the top ladder players in new leagues especially in HC are using daggers atm so that should tell you something - it's broken good but only when you are established.

Think of it as a treat for accumulating the gear together, because make no mistake - it's good because it's expensive.
IGN: Chundaziri
8/8 Ambush/Invasion Complete - 21/06/2014
8/8 Warbands/Tempest Complete - 10/08/2015
Last edited by Chundadragon#1131 on Aug 25, 2014, 7:11:53 PM

Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info