Guild Feedback (From the leader of a large guild)

"

CharanJaydemyr wrote:

You have a funny definition of 'bothered'. I'm just bantering.

I do that. A lot.

Besides, you're the one who felt it necessary to point how big it was. Your guild, that is. And then ask how I felt about that.

So who's taking it seriously, eh? ^_^

Also, you sort of got it wrong. It's not 100 per member. It's 10 per member.

I was actually considering writing an "inb4 Charan talks about himself" - but I didn't, it was too obvious. Yea, sure I did write about my guild - as an joke - you didn't get it, I might have to add more emoticons next time.

Your last comment is just low. Let's leave it here.

EDIT: If you have to continue this, I can't see any other solution than to have a PvP-fight between our guilds.

Bump to show my support for these suggestions.

I'm the leader of the largest reddit guild (of 3, since 200 account slots isn't cutting it). All these issues make running the guild more tedious than it needs to be. The biggest issue for me thus far is inactivity. I want to free up space for more people, but I'm hesitant to kick anyone because there's no way to keep track of who's been playing and who hasn't.

If last login for a guild member could be displayed, it would be a huge help.

To add a suggestion, allow us to rename guilds. It can cost GGGold, but right now I'm hesitant to buy guild stash tabs because I'm not sure about the guild name.

"

VorcePA wrote:

Bump to show my support for these suggestions.

I'm the leader of the largest reddit guild (of 3, since 200 account slots isn't cutting it). All these issues make running the guild more tedious than it needs to be. The biggest issue for me thus far is inactivity. I want to free up space for more people, but I'm hesitant to kick anyone because there's no way to keep track of who's been playing and who hasn't.

If last login for a guild member could be displayed, it would be a huge help.

This. I reallly need to see who is inactive, so I can free up space for others who are interested in joining.

And please GGG - raise the limit for maximum members.

I have about 37 people in my guild and counting.

Biggest issue I've ran into so far has all ready been mentioned:

Setting up the tabs for individual leagues is bothersome.


I also want to second: Change the guild chat button to something other than "&". It's really quite annoying for those of us with small hands. And as a guild leader, I'm constantly stopping to answer people's questions.


Now for what I wanted to add:
My biggest complaint though is that there needs to be a third group (outside of Members and Officers). Basically, for those who have been suspended. That way I can simply throw an offending person into the suspended group instead of simply kicking them only to reinvite later (which means I am being punished as well).

Or simply give us options for muting people and/or taking away some of their privileges.

Just please don't make it a blanket option.


Oh, I thought of another thing I wanted to second (honestly, there's quite a lot on the first page that I agree with): Let us see what leagues people are in like on the friends list (not exactly how it's done there, just a smaller symbol or something). My guild is pretty split on HC and SC. It'd make life easier for all of us if we knew at a glance what league people were playing in without having to ask.

Another Suggestion:

Have a small area on the guild screen for short messages from the leader or officers. Doesn't have to be a big area. Just enough to leave important messages such as reminders for codes of conduct or instructions on using the stash. That kind of thing. Put it in the area where on my screen I can type the status or change the guild tag.

Support nearly all the changes on here! PLEASE listen GGG

Adding to this:

It would be a nice feature if the guild leader and officers had the ability to control+click items to and from the guild stash like everyone can with their own stash. Those in charge of organizing the guild stashes will agree having to manually click each individual item to move it is time consuming.

I like the idea that not everyone can control+click items into the guild stash it helps to prevent people from dumping a ton of stuff into the guild stashes quickly and from people removing items just as fast, but for the people in the guild managing/arranging the guild stash tabs it's a pain.

With regards to member slots, it would be peachy if players could pay to unlock their account from taking up a slot on a guild. By this I mean if a player chooses to buy a slot-pass or something, they could join any guild they want without taking up a guild slot.

This would of course mean any normal guild can have up to 30 F2P players on it before expanding, but if a new member wants to join and has a slot-pass, they could be the 31st member without the guild master having to buy an extra 10 slots.

As long as guild masters and officers could inspect to see if a new eligible member already has a slot-pass, it wouldn't be too much of an issue.

If each member could buy the slot-pass for 10 points, it would be much easier than having to forward $1 from each member through an online money transfer to the Guild master. ($1 across PayPal? I think the fees are more than just $1).

i would like to see a log on guild stash, items taken out and items placed.
i just logged in to find all the gold items gone and no way of telling who did it.
more member ranks would be appreciated as just members and officers is a bit limited.