Summon Skeletons + Added Chaos Damage

Hey guys, I'm playing a summoner build on anarchy and have a few questions about the mechanics of skeletons + chaos damage. Theoretically, the chaos damage is considered to be minion damage. Therefore, the increased minion damage gem, passives and attributes from items should increase the chaos damage dealt. But the tooltip says otherwise, so I'd really like some confirmation. Preferably from someone who has tried it and/or a dev. Here are the questions:

1. Do minion damage passives increase the chaos damage dealt?

2. Does the minion damage support gem increase the chaos damage dealt?

3. Do attributes of items, such as Sidhebreath (+15% inc minion dmg) increase the chaos damage dealt?

Thank you in advance :).
"
RePoE_Man wrote:
Hey guys, I'm playing a summoner build on anarchy and have a few questions about the mechanics of skeletons + chaos damage. Theoretically, the chaos damage is considered to be minion damage. Therefore, the increased minion damage gem, passives and attributes from items should increase the chaos damage dealt. But the tooltip says otherwise, so I'd really like some confirmation. Preferably from someone who has tried it and/or a dev. Here are the questions:

1. Do minion damage passives increase the chaos damage dealt?

2. Does the minion damage support gem increase the chaos damage dealt?

3. Do attributes of items, such as Sidhebreath (+15% inc minion dmg) increase the chaos damage dealt?

Thank you in advance :).


where have you ever seen chaos damg. as minion damg.? minion damg. is all physical damg. until you apply any support gems on them which will then give them additional elem. damg.(along with physical) like fire, cold, lightning and chaos. but to answer all your questions the answer would be all no.
"
banezilla wrote:
"
RePoE_Man wrote:
Hey guys, I'm playing a summoner build on anarchy and have a few questions about the mechanics of skeletons + chaos damage. Theoretically, the chaos damage is considered to be minion damage. Therefore, the increased minion damage gem, passives and attributes from items should increase the chaos damage dealt. But the tooltip says otherwise, so I'd really like some confirmation. Preferably from someone who has tried it and/or a dev. Here are the questions:

1. Do minion damage passives increase the chaos damage dealt?

2. Does the minion damage support gem increase the chaos damage dealt?

3. Do attributes of items, such as Sidhebreath (+15% inc minion dmg) increase the chaos damage dealt?

Thank you in advance :).


where have you ever seen chaos damg. as minion damg.? minion damg. is all physical damg. until you apply any support gems on them which will then give them additional elem. damg.(along with physical) like fire, cold, lightning and chaos. but to answer all your questions the answer would be all no.


The only thing I can think of is he may have meant specters that deal chaos damage (ie degen bears)
I'm talking about the skill Summon Skeletons and the support gem Added Chaos Damage. When you support a spell or projectile with added chaos damage, the chaos damage is increased by %spell damage and/or %projectile damage. Similarly, I thought if you support a minion with added chaos damage, the chaos damage would be increased by %minion damage.
"
recurring wrote:
"
banezilla wrote:
"
RePoE_Man wrote:
Hey guys, I'm playing a summoner build on anarchy and have a few questions about the mechanics of skeletons + chaos damage. Theoretically, the chaos damage is considered to be minion damage. Therefore, the increased minion damage gem, passives and attributes from items should increase the chaos damage dealt. But the tooltip says otherwise, so I'd really like some confirmation. Preferably from someone who has tried it and/or a dev. Here are the questions:

1. Do minion damage passives increase the chaos damage dealt?

2. Does the minion damage support gem increase the chaos damage dealt?

3. Do attributes of items, such as Sidhebreath (+15% inc minion dmg) increase the chaos damage dealt?

Thank you in advance :).


where have you ever seen chaos damg. as minion damg.? minion damg. is all physical damg. until you apply any support gems on them which will then give them additional elem. damg.(along with physical) like fire, cold, lightning and chaos. but to answer all your questions the answer would be all no.


The only thing I can think of is he may have meant specters that deal chaos damage (ie degen bears)


could be but don't think so, his English is good so don't think he lacks the understanding of how to write what he wants to get across and he does stat he's asking about "mechanics of skeletons + chaos damage". I'm just thinking that somewhere down the line he has misunderstood what chaos damg. is.
"
banezilla wrote:


where have you ever seen chaos damg. as minion damg.? minion damg. is all physical damg. until you apply any support gems on them which will then give them additional elem. damg.(along with physical) like fire, cold, lightning and chaos. but to answer all your questions the answer would be all no.


I'm talking about the skill Summon Skeletons and the support gem Added Chaos Damage. When you support a spell or projectile with added chaos damage, the chaos damage is increased by %spell damage and/or %projectile damage. Similarly, I thought if you support a minion with added chaos damage, the chaos damage would be increased by %minion damage.

And could you explain further banez, what makes you say no? Have you tried it, or are you just saying no based off other mechanics?
"
RePoE_Man wrote:
I'm talking about the skill Summon Skeletons and the support gem Added Chaos Damage. When you support a spell or projectile with added chaos damage, the chaos damage is increased by %spell damage and/or %projectile damage. Similarly, I thought if you support a minion with added chaos damage, the chaos damage would be increased by %minion damage.


chaos damg. is its own damg. and wont scale up with % nodes from spell or projectile, however some items and skills use physical damg. converted to chaos damg. which will then make your chaos damg. scale up with projectile damg. cause thats physical damg.
"
RePoE_Man wrote:
"
banezilla wrote:


where have you ever seen chaos damg. as minion damg.? minion damg. is all physical damg. until you apply any support gems on them which will then give them additional elem. damg.(along with physical) like fire, cold, lightning and chaos. but to answer all your questions the answer would be all no.


I'm talking about the skill Summon Skeletons and the support gem Added Chaos Damage. When you support a spell or projectile with added chaos damage, the chaos damage is increased by %spell damage and/or %projectile damage. Similarly, I thought if you support a minion with added chaos damage, the chaos damage would be increased by %minion damage.

And could you explain further banez, what makes you say no? Have you tried it, or are you just saying no based off other mechanics?


taking minion damg. nodes only truly adds physical damg. then any supports that are based off of that damg. would increase, like added fire damg. gem or so on. but chaos damg. gem is its own damg. and don't get increases from any elem. damg. nodes or spell nodes. its just a flat damg. increase from the gem.
Last edited by banezilla#2919 on Jul 24, 2013, 9:00:10 PM
I'm still unsure about the minion damage, but I know you are incorrect about chaos damage and spell/projectile damage. I have no damage conversions and I am using a LvL 1 Added Chaos Damage gem (16-25 damage). When I support my cold snap with it, the chaos damage dealt is not 16-25, rather it is 17-27 because I have 9% increased spell damage.

Perhaps the tooltip for Summon Skeletons is broken? I tried supporting it with LvL 1 Added Lightning Damage (1-7 damage) and the tooltip still reads 1-7. The skill states it should deal 50% less elemental damage, so shouldn't it be 1-3 or 1-4?
Last edited by RePoE_Man#5309 on Jul 24, 2013, 6:53:23 PM
"
RePoE_Man wrote:
I'm still unsure about the minion damage, but I know you are incorrect about chaos damage and spell/projectile damage. I have no damage conversions and I am using a LvL 1 Added Chaos Damage gem (16-25 damage). When I support my cold snap with it, the chaos damage dealt is not 16-25, rather it is 17-27 because I have 9% increased spell damage.

Perhaps the tooltip for Summon Skeletons is broken? I tried supporting it with LvL 1 Added Lightning Damage (1-7 damage) and the tooltip still reads 1-7. The skill states it should deal 50% less elemental damage, so shouldn't it be 1-3 or 1-4?


yes your right about the added spell damg. that was my bad but for any attk. damg. it wont scale up. here is quote from Mark in the chaos support gem thread:

"
Mark_GGG wrote:
"
aurisacra wrote:
There was a discussion in global the other night suggesting that +Added Chaos dmg was affected by +spell dmg passives (but not +elemental).

I forget who it was, but they stated that they were clearly getting +spell damage bonuses to the overall damage of their Ice Spear (I think) with Chaos Support.
Well, yes, because Ice Spear is a spell. That won't happen if you use this support on an attack.
Spell damage increases the damage done by spells, so if you use the chaos damage support on a spell then the chaos damage is spell damage and will be affected by increases to spell damage.


Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info