The Ruler of Highgate Quest Ending

So why is it that when you talk to Irasha or Tasuni they just take the feather. The quest is worded in such a way that makes the player expect the option to be like that of picking a bandit not a standard hand in quest. As far as I understand the rewards are the same but I would have still liked to have been able to chose instead of having the very important feather ripped from my inventory by accidentally talking to one of the two. This can also result in people who want to pick one of them but end up stuck with the other because one happened to be closer or they wanted to know what the other said.

TLDR:The main character is not a baby holding a candy (Feather) and should be able to choice (Like bandits) who he gives it too instead of having it ripped from his hands.

+1

+1

How about also a third option (give it to Petarus and Vania cuz they're gonna sell it on the black market or something). Oh, and maybe different rewards depending on your choice, something like... umm, let me think... what could we possibly want... I don't know... maybe... an extra Endurance, Frenzy or Power charge!

100% needs to be fleshed out more like those... charges some one mentioned... hinthint... nudgenudge...