Can't return kulemak's finger.

Tried the fight multiple times. Only get option to take finger. Abyss progression is pretty much bricked.

Same when using an Xbox Controller, 2 invitations both wasted.

I also had this issue but when i pressed "x" (PS5 console) to take the finger, it gave me another prompt, in this case I was able to select either option...not sure if that worked for others. I initially tried to relog, reconnect, also messed around with the controls and bindings but i eventually gave up and pressed X, but it gave me another option after that.