All Ears Achievement

Is this even possible? I have tried several LISTS, at least four leagues, with seven characters and I never match the WIKI or anyone's lists.

If they plan to give us this Achievement Quest at least make sure we have a real good update freaking list!

blah ...

You have to be very careful while pursuing All Ears, because some dialogue becomes unavailable if you do things out of order. Make one simple mistake and the achievement is broken until you start a new char and try again. And a lot of the time you won't know that it's broken or what it was that you missed.

The list on the Wiki is up to date and has all the proper steps. The requirements for the achievement haven't changed in several years, I believe. People do still post about having just completed it, so it is definitely still working. You've just missed things or done something out of order in your attempts.

I am following the wiki, some of the dialog it lists by a certain character came from a different char. If it's the BANDITS, those should be ruled out unless it says you have to KILL all in order to complete this achievement because it does not say that, the wiki shows conversations with the bandits after killing them and that's impossible unless you helped one ... and you can't help all three.

I did it several leagues ago, and this is not mine, but I used this specific guide:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1RWPN_NO3wcl7QRTHP6iTONG-T47VForpQgZ-eN2IQzc/edit#gid=1992142767

I still had it bookmarked, but as I see it now, it was not updated after patch 3.9.

But it shall still be a good base I think, as it has lot of special notes helping out, like one for instance for the bandits, "Do not kill any bandits until AFTER The Darkness".

I also remember having problem when I first tried it with some removed Zana dialogues at Oriath, but that was patched later, and this was doable again for a time for sure for some leagues.

OK, so I have been wanting to get this global achievement done for 10+ years. Is it remotely possible in 3.21? I see the guide for 3.9 (with prophecy, which of course is now gone) and that could help a bunch, but with all the new masters and league mechanics rolled in ... I worry about trying this and being like 1 off at the end.

I got mine last league so it is indeed possible.

This should still be fine, just remember to follow exactly:

https://www.poewiki.net/wiki/All_Ears