[Nemesis] Need Advice on my two builds.

Hello Im struggling about which to choose in between my two final builds for my Storm caller scion so far im lvl 75. (nemesis)

And this is my current build.




But in the end im aiming for these one but just cannot decide.
#1

#2

Im comparing the left side of the skill tree to be more closer to marauder or templar.

So #1 has 38%add life / 30max life / 43%armor 1.9life reg
and #2 has 58% add life /30 max life /44 armor / 1 life reg.

So my right hand says dude go for life ! 20%!! ( and could prob get an other +8%) so 28%

But my left hand is saying 30% reduced Extra Damage from Critical Strikes / 30% Flask faster recovery is worth losing the 20-28% add life.


So I would like some advice on which to decide to. #1 or #2?