Need your opinion (or your math)

Assuming a character is dealing:
1.5k-3k physical damage
6k-11k cold damage
with an attack using 5 links and tool-tipping 52.5k

For that 6th link, which gem would potentially maximize true DPS total, using these options:
Cold Penetration - 37% cold penetration
Slower Projectiles - 30% MORE proj. damage

With slower projectiles I'm tool-tipping 68.6k
With Cold Penetration I'm tool-tipping 53.1k

I do understand that tool-tip DPS calculations are not always accurate and are not inclusive to things like penetration.

So, which gem would maximize my DPS potential?


Last edited by SymbiosisPhotography on May 22, 2016, 2:04:27 AM
Last bumped on May 23, 2016, 2:41:10 AM
"
Assuming a character is dealing:
1.5k-3k physical damage
6k-11k cold damage
with an attack using 5 links and tool-tipping 52.5k

For that 6th link, which gem would potentially maximize true DPS total, using these options:
Cold Penetration - 37% cold penetration
Slower Projectiles - 30% MORE proj. damage

With slower projectiles I'm tool-tipping 68.6k
With Cold Penetration I'm tool-tipping 53.1k

I do understand that tool-tip DPS calculations are not always accurate and are not inclusive to things like penetration.

So, which gem would maximize my DPS potential?



cold penetration is better and i think every cold skill should use it,and slower projectiles may be bad if the skill ur using have a set duration (like freezing pulse)it would reduce the skill range
Last edited by marcos459 on May 22, 2016, 2:12:58 AM
Well, like I said, it's an attack not a spell. Thank you for replying.
Last edited by SymbiosisPhotography on May 22, 2016, 2:16:57 AM
Could I get another reply? Just curious to get more feedback on this.
Youd have to tell us the skill to be honest, im assuming frostblade or something with 25% additional conversion or something with Hrimnor gloves or something ?
Harvest sucks! But look at my decked out gear two weeks in!

Labyrinth salt farm miner.

"But my build diversity" , "Game is too hard!" - Meta drone playing the same 1-3 builds for years.
Siege Ballista
Last edited by SymbiosisPhotography on May 23, 2016, 2:04:55 AM
"
Siege Ballista
In that case i believe the slower projectiles tooltip is indeed accurate here. It affects both your physical and cold damage over all, while the cold penetration will only essentially give you "37% more cold damage".

I could be wrong but i think thats correct.
Harvest sucks! But look at my decked out gear two weeks in!

Labyrinth salt farm miner.

"But my build diversity" , "Game is too hard!" - Meta drone playing the same 1-3 builds for years.
real dps with pen will depend on mob resists

if mobs are capped, they will have 38 resists, so about 200% more dps
if mobs have 30 resists, you will do 53% more dps
if mobs have zero resist, you will do 37% more dps
if mobs have -30 resist, you will do 28% more dps

the more resists the mob has, the better your actual dps multiplier

in the case of your skill, cold pen is a clear winner. yes, slower proj will benefit both the phys part and cold part. BUT you will benefit from cold pen when it matters most (resistant mobs). plus, slower projectile will make the ballista shoot much slower moving arrows (been there, done that lol) whereas cold pen doesnt have any downside to it
Last edited by grepman on May 23, 2016, 2:23:22 AM
"
grepman wrote:
real dps with pen will depend on mob resists

if mobs are capped, they will have 38 resists, so about 200% more dps
if mobs have 30 resists, you will do 53% more dps
if mobs have zero resist, you will do 37% more dps
if mobs have -30 resist, you will do 28% more dps

the more resists the mob has, the better your actual dps multiplier

in the case of your skill, cold pen is a clear winner. yes, slower proj will benefit both the phys part and cold part. BUT you will benefit from cold pen when it matters most (resistant mobs). plus, slower projectile will make the ballista shoot much slower moving arrows (been there, done that lol) whereas cold pen doesnt have any downside to it
Da true math hero.
Harvest sucks! But look at my decked out gear two weeks in!

Labyrinth salt farm miner.

"But my build diversity" , "Game is too hard!" - Meta drone playing the same 1-3 builds for years.
Fully appreciated.

In PvP, I assume, cold pen would also be a the clear winner, as most players should have cap resists?

Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info